{
 "pass": {
  "name": "claude/2026-09-21/rabanne-brands-1",
  "kind": "session",
  "process_version": "7",
  "rules_version": "6",
  "generator": "claude-session",
  "verdict": "proposals",
  "fingerprint": "d5a6abd0c6501ed83743ae1e02fc05cd6fe1ce9341def3bb938dfd9573be4a79",
  "note": "Brand layer under process version 7, rehearsed on a copy (K13.8). Research: Puig announced in June 2023 that Paco Rabanne becomes Rabanne; the travel-retail launch followed the same year (Moodie Davitt Report).",
  "survey": [
   {
    "kind": "a brand that renamed itself, written under both names by different retailers",
    "precedent": "brand:renamed-house",
    "registered": true,
    "examples": [
     "listing:extime/CDG/13100",
     "listing:attenza/BOG/42758810075211"
    ],
    "question": "Are Paco Rabanne and Rabanne one brand, and which row survives?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "a product line named without the brand word once the brand row changes",
    "precedent": null,
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:extime/CDG/13100"
    ],
    "question": "Is Pour Homme the same product line as Paco Pour Homme once the brands are one?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "a deodorant listed under a scent's name",
    "precedent": "membership:deodorant-under-scent",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:extime/CDG/100885570"
    ],
    "question": "Is a deodorant a member of the scent's product line, told apart by its form, or its own product line?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "a refill listed under a scent's name",
    "precedent": "membership:refill-one-line",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:extime/CDG/101090625"
    ],
    "question": "Is a refill that fits exactly one product line a member of it?"
   }
  ]
 },
 "brand": "rabanne",
 "proposals": [
  {
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:brand:brand:paco-rabanne||brand:rabanne",
    "detail": {
     "level": "brand"
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "same",
    "survivor": "brand:rabanne",
    "name": "Rabanne",
    "note": null
   },
   "confidence": 0.95,
   "attention": "medium",
   "subjectivity": "settled",
   "precedent": "brand:renamed-house",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention_why": "sure after checking the rename; settled by the ruling that a renamed brand folds into its new name; but it moves 24 product lines, 55 product variants and 54 listings, so a look rather than the pile",
   "reason": "These are the same brand. Paco Rabanne became Rabanne in 2023, when Puig dropped the first name; three retailers now write Rabanne on 157 listings and one still writes Paco Rabanne on 54, and the two rows share fifteen product line keys. The new name survives, as the ruling on renamed brands says.",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:extime/CDG/13100",
     "source": "listed_brand",
     "span": [
      0,
      12
     ],
     "text": "Paco Rabanne"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/BOG/42758810075211",
     "source": "listed_brand",
     "span": [
      0,
      7
     ],
     "text": "Rabanne"
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "position": 1,
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:da7c4a13-4033-4ca8-ba90-6594a239a58a",
   "held_behind": "pair:brand:brand:paco-rabanne||brand:rabanne",
   "entity": {
    "type": "product_variant",
    "key": "variant:23fa056f-a261-4c49-be36-a9009129679e",
    "detail": {
     "listings": [
      "listing:extime/CDG/13100"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "product_line",
   "value": "line:da7c4a13-4033-4ca8-ba90-6594a239a58a",
   "confidence": 0.9,
   "attention": "low",
   "subjectivity": "fact",
   "attention_why": "sure: the one shop that writes Pour Homme under the old brand name is naming the 1973 scent the other shop writes in full; a fact of the words; one product variant moves",
   "reason": "Once the brands are one, this shop's Pour Homme is the same product line as the Paco Rabanne Pour Homme Eau de Toilette the other shop writes in full: the brand's original men's scent, written without the brand word.",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:extime/CDG/13100",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      10
     ],
     "text": "Pour Homme"
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "position": 2,
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:e9d13f97-a24f-4618-a721-cfc7701b8db0",
   "held_behind": "pair:brand:brand:paco-rabanne||brand:rabanne",
   "entity": {
    "type": "product_variant",
    "key": "variant:74131778-9958-448f-b041-13729e3c704f",
    "detail": {
     "listings": [
      "listing:extime/CDG/100885570"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "product_line",
   "value": "line:e9d13f97-a24f-4618-a721-cfc7701b8db0",
   "confidence": 0.8,
   "attention": "critical",
   "subjectivity": "judgement",
   "precedent": "membership:deodorant-under-scent",
   "precedent_status": "sets",
   "attention_why": "fairly sure of the words; a real call nobody has ruled on, and the answer also decides the Invictus and One Million deodorants the catalogue keeps apart today; one product variant moves now",
   "reason": "A deodorant sold under a scent's name: I would make it a member of the Phantom product line told apart by its form, so a shopper looking for Phantom sees everything sold under that name, but the catalogue keeps the Invictus and One Million deodorants as their own product lines today and this answer decides those too.",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:extime/CDG/100885570",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      17
     ],
     "text": "Phantom Deo Spray"
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "position": 3,
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:2dc368b3-5016-452e-a10b-306d1c618e48",
   "held_behind": "pair:brand:brand:paco-rabanne||brand:rabanne",
   "entity": {
    "type": "product_variant",
    "key": "variant:0d2c240f-5979-4ee6-95e3-fb9edaeccb76",
    "detail": {
     "listings": [
      "listing:extime/CDG/101090625"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "product_line",
   "value": "line:2dc368b3-5016-452e-a10b-306d1c618e48",
   "confidence": 0.85,
   "attention": "high",
   "subjectivity": "judgement",
   "precedent": "membership:refill-one-line",
   "precedent_status": "sets",
   "attention_why": "sure of the words; a call with no ruling yet, though the guidance leans this way; one product variant moves",
   "reason": "A refill that fits exactly one product line: Fame Refill is the Fame scent in a refill bottle, so I would make it a member of Fame told apart by its form rather than its own product line.",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:extime/CDG/101090625",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      11
     ],
     "text": "Fame Refill"
    }
   ]
  }
 ]
}