{
 "pass": {
  "name": "claude/2026-09-20/rabanne-product_lines-1",
  "kind": "session",
  "process_version": "6",
  "rules_version": "6",
  "generator": "claude-session",
  "note": "Layer product_lines. The brands layer holds no question I can see: the packet carries only this brand's own family, which is the single row rabanne with no aliases, so a join to a brand row outside that family is not visible from here. cross_divide_candidates is empty, and every listing in the packet comes from a retailer that publishes listed words, so that layer has nothing to judge either. No notes and no parked questions. The precedent register is empty, so all fifteen kinds in the survey are new and every lead is critical by construction. Seven kinds are surveyed and not proposed on: the flanker question and the word-or-digit spelling, because nothing in the words decides them; four that belong to the product variant and attribute layers, which this layer may only raise; and the empty product line rows, which the file format has no field for beyond the two the proposals already absorb.",
  "survey": [
   {
    "kind": "A set of bottles that names one product line and no other",
    "precedent": "membership:set-one-line",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:attenza/PTY/51191287415064",
     "listing:attenza/BOG/42758810730571"
    ],
    "question": "Does a set naming exactly one product line belong inside that product line, or is it a product line of its own?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "A set holding bottles from several product lines",
    "precedent": "membership:set-spans-lines",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:attenza/BOG/42758810697803",
     "listing:attenza/PTY/51191287480600"
    ],
    "question": "Where does a set go when it names four bottles from three product lines?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "An audience word on some sibling names and absent on one",
    "precedent": "membership:audience-marked",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:attenza/PTY/51191285678360",
     "listing:attenza/BOG/42758808961099"
    ],
    "question": "Is the unmarked row the men's scent, the women's, or a name covering both? Marked: Black XS For Him, Black XS For Her, Million Gold For Her. Unmarked: Black Xs, Million Gold."
   },
   {
    "kind": "A leading family word present on some listings and absent on others",
    "precedent": "name-a-product-line:head-word-dropped",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:attenza/BOG/42758810140747",
     "listing:attenza/PTY/51191286956312"
    ],
    "question": "Are One Million Gold and Million Gold one product line, and which spelling names it?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "The concentration words left inside a product line's name",
    "precedent": "membership:concentration-in-the-name",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:avolta/ATH/6981416",
     "listing:avolta/ZRH/6981416"
    ],
    "question": "Is Paco Rosé Eau de Toilette a product line of its own, or Paco Rosé with the concentration held on the product variant?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "The same audience phrase written in two languages",
    "precedent": "name-a-product-line:translation-pair",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:attenza/BOG/42758810828875",
     "listing:attenza/PTY/51191287841048"
    ],
    "question": "Are Pour Homme and For Him one product line, and which spelling names it?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "The brand's former name written in full inside the listed name",
    "precedent": "name-a-product-line:former-brand-name-in-the-name",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:attenza/BOG/42758541377611",
     "listing:ari/YUL/41434724204621"
    ],
    "question": "When a shop writes Paco Rabanne in full, is the leftover word part of the product line's name or part of the brand's?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "A deodorant carrying a fragrance's name",
    "precedent": "membership:format-under-a-scent-name",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:avolta/HEL/3349668515752",
     "listing:avolta/ZRH/3349666007990"
    ],
    "question": "Does a toiletry sold under a scent's name belong inside that scent's product line, told apart by an attribute, or is it a product line of its own?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "A flanker word beside the plain scent",
    "precedent": "membership:flanker-own-line",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:attenza/BOG/42758809485387",
     "listing:attenza/BOG/42758809714763"
    ],
    "question": "Does a flanker such as Invictus Victory, Invictus Aqua, Fame In Love, Phantom in Red or Lady Million Royal name its own product line, or is it a member of the parent's told apart by an attribute? Nothing in the words decides it, so I have proposed nothing and left every flanker where it stands."
   },
   {
    "kind": "The family head written as a word and as a digit",
    "precedent": "name-a-product-line:number-word-or-digit",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:avolta/ZRH/3349666007990",
     "listing:ari/YUL/41900908118093"
    ],
    "question": "Do One Million and 1 Million name one family, and which spelling does the catalogue use? No shop writes the digit form of the deodorant, so there is no value to propose from the words."
   },
   {
    "kind": "One shop prints the concentration and its sibling shops do not, on one article number",
    "precedent": "product-variant:concentration-silent-at-one-shop",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:avolta/LGW/1002215",
     "listing:avolta/ATH/1002215"
    ],
    "question": "Is a silent listing the same product variant as the one that states the concentration? This splits Paco and Paco Rosé into two product variants each, and belongs to the product variant layer."
   },
   {
    "kind": "The same bottle's concentration written two ways by sibling shops",
    "precedent": "attribute:elixir-read-two-ways",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:attenza/BOG/42758808895563",
     "listing:attenza/PTY/51191285547288"
    ],
    "question": "Which concentration does an Elixir carry when one shop writes Eau de Parfum Intense and another Parfum Intense? An attribute layer question."
   },
   {
    "kind": "A set's stated quantity contradicts its own name",
    "precedent": "attribute:set-quantity-contradicts-the-name",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:attenza/SAL/48553632792768",
     "listing:attenza/PTY/51191287611672"
    ],
    "question": "Which number is a set's quantity, the member its name states or the figure in the shop's own size field? An attribute layer question, and it decides what a set's price is compared against."
   },
   {
    "kind": "A product line row with no product variants left on it",
    "precedent": "product-line:empty-row",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:attenza/PTY/52108250743064",
     "listing:attenza/PTY/51191287841048"
    ],
    "question": "For Him and XS For Him hold nothing: their listings sit on other product lines. Does such a row go, or stay as a spelling that keeps resolving? The proposals above absorb both, which answers it for these two only."
   },
   {
    "kind": "A product variant with no listings under it",
    "precedent": "product-variant:no-listings",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:attenza/BOG/42758540689483",
     "listing:attenza/PTY/51191287513368"
    ],
    "question": "Four set product variants hold no listing at all. Is such a row one to keep or a leftover to prune? A product variant layer question."
   }
  ],
  "verdict": "proposals",
  "fingerprint": "d5a6abd0c6501ed83743ae1e02fc05cd6fe1ce9341def3bb938dfd9573be4a79"
 },
 "brand": "rabanne",
 "proposals": [
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:new:rabanne-1-million",
   "entity": {
    "type": "product_line",
    "key": "line:new:rabanne-1-million",
    "detail": {
     "brand_slug": "rabanne",
     "slug": "rabanne-1-million",
     "name": "1 Million",
     "absorbs": [
      "line:b21899c5-0b2d-4cec-aeba-72b6cf1c28cd"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "name",
   "value": "1 Million",
   "confidence": 0.85,
   "reason": "The words name one product line and no other: a duo of two 1 Million eau de toilette bottles. Nothing is settled for sets yet, and I would put this one inside 1 Million, because a set naming a single product line is that product line at another quantity and a shopper comparing 1 Million should be shown it. Three more sets wait on this answer: Set Fame Fame into Fame, Set Invictus Invictus into Invictus, and both Million Gold For Her sets into Million Gold For Her.",
   "precedent": "membership:set-one-line",
   "precedent_status": "sets",
   "attention": "critical",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/PTY/51191287415064",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      13,
      42
     ],
     "text": "Duo 1 Million Eau de Toilette"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/BOG/42758808436811",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      25
     ],
     "text": "1 Million Eau de Toilette"
    }
   ],
   "position": 0
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:new:rabanne-fame",
   "entity": {
    "type": "product_line",
    "key": "line:new:rabanne-fame",
    "detail": {
     "brand_slug": "rabanne",
     "slug": "rabanne-fame",
     "name": "Fame",
     "absorbs": [
      "line:c69c47d2-1bd5-4283-9d75-3f6730e2c2f5"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "name",
   "value": "Fame",
   "confidence": 0.9,
   "reason": "The words name one product line twice at two quantities, Fame eau de parfum at 80 ml and at 20 ml, so this is the same case as the 1 Million duo and goes with that answer.",
   "precedent": "membership:set-one-line",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "follows": "line:new:rabanne-1-million",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/BOG/42758810730571",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      13,
      64
     ],
     "text": "Fame Eau de Parfum 80 ml + Fame Eau de Parfum 20 ml"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/BOG/42758809059403",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      18
     ],
     "text": "Fame Eau de Parfum"
    }
   ],
   "position": 1
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:new:rabanne-invictus",
   "entity": {
    "type": "product_line",
    "key": "line:new:rabanne-invictus",
    "detail": {
     "brand_slug": "rabanne",
     "slug": "rabanne-invictus",
     "name": "Invictus",
     "absorbs": [
      "line:f30cf74c-f756-467b-a076-f32f79d65188"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "name",
   "value": "Invictus",
   "confidence": 0.9,
   "reason": "The words name one product line twice, Invictus eau de toilette with a 20 ml of the same scent, so this is the same case as the 1 Million duo and goes with that answer.",
   "precedent": "membership:set-one-line",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "follows": "line:new:rabanne-1-million",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/PTY/51191287611672",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      13,
      70
     ],
     "text": "Invictus Eau de Toilette + Invictus Eau de Toilette 20 ml"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/BOG/42758809485387",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      24
     ],
     "text": "Invictus Eau de Toilette"
    }
   ],
   "position": 2
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:new:rabanne-million-gold-for-her",
   "entity": {
    "type": "product_line",
    "key": "line:new:rabanne-million-gold-for-her",
    "detail": {
     "brand_slug": "rabanne",
     "slug": "rabanne-million-gold-for-her",
     "name": "Million Gold For Her",
     "absorbs": [
      "line:ad5c22b8-86e2-4949-872c-5ec5e75ace04",
      "line:3320425a-15d4-4960-b916-6fd2980e3498"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "name",
   "value": "Million Gold For Her",
   "confidence": 0.8,
   "reason": "Both of these name Million Gold For Her and nothing else: one is the eau de parfum with a 15 ml of itself, the other a 20 ml set written without the word For. Same case as the 1 Million duo, so they go with that answer.",
   "precedent": "membership:set-one-line",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "follows": "line:new:rabanne-1-million",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/PTY/51191287644440",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      13,
      89
     ],
     "text": "Million Gold For Her Eau de Parfum + Million Gold For Her Eau de Parfum 15ml"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/BOG/42758540689483",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      25
     ],
     "text": "Million Gold Her Set 20ml"
    }
   ],
   "position": 3
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:b3f9c620-a5a2-407f-bff7-a61b04e044c6",
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:line:line:2dc368b3-5016-452e-a10b-306d1c618e48||line:b3f9c620-a5a2-407f-bff7-a61b04e044c6",
    "detail": {
     "sides": [
      {
       "key": "line:2dc368b3-5016-452e-a10b-306d1c618e48",
       "kind": "product_line",
       "name": "Fame"
      },
      {
       "key": "line:b3f9c620-a5a2-407f-bff7-a61b04e044c6",
       "kind": "product_line",
       "name": "Set Fame Fame Lady Million Olympéa"
      }
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate",
    "note": "A set spanning several product lines stays its own product line."
   },
   "confidence": 0.9,
   "reason": "This set holds four bottles from three product lines, Fame, Lady Million and Olympéa, so it cannot sit inside any one of them. There is no precedent for this yet. I would leave it as its own product line, because otherwise one product variant would have to sit under several product lines at once.",
   "precedent": "membership:set-spans-lines",
   "precedent_status": "sets",
   "attention": "critical",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/BOG/42758810697803",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      13,
      118
     ],
     "text": "Fame Eau de Parfum 4 ml + Fame Parfum 4 ml + Lady Million Eau de Parfum 5 ml + Olympéa Eau de Parfum 6 ml"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/PTY/51191286825240",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      21
     ],
     "text": "Olympéa Eau de Parfum"
    }
   ],
   "position": 4
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:new:rabanne-black-xs",
   "entity": {
    "type": "product_line",
    "key": "line:new:rabanne-black-xs",
    "detail": {
     "brand_slug": "rabanne",
     "slug": "rabanne-black-xs",
     "name": "Black XS",
     "absorbs": [
      "line:c7d9f438-24fc-4554-a7b2-9776b3a09c25"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "name",
   "value": "Black XS",
   "confidence": 0.7,
   "reason": "One retailer sells Black Xs eau de toilette at 100 ml in Bogota and San Salvador and Black XS For Him eau de toilette at 100 ml in Panama, while Black XS For Her is an 80 ml eau de parfum. The unmarked spelling could be the men's scent, the women's, or a name covering both; I read it as the men's, because its concentration and its quantity match the For Him rows exactly and match neither For Her row. Million Gold beside Million Gold For Her is the same shape and I have left those two apart: their concentrations and quantities do not meet.",
   "precedent": "membership:audience-marked",
   "precedent_status": "sets",
   "attention": "critical",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/PTY/51191285678360",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      8
     ],
     "text": "Black XS"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/BOG/42758808961099",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      24
     ],
     "text": "Black Xs Eau de Toilette"
    }
   ],
   "position": 5
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:new:rabanne-million-gold",
   "entity": {
    "type": "product_line",
    "key": "line:new:rabanne-million-gold",
    "detail": {
     "brand_slug": "rabanne",
     "slug": "rabanne-million-gold",
     "name": "Million Gold",
     "absorbs": [
      "line:442b076a-decf-449b-a907-510e5f9d9bfa"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "name",
   "value": "Million Gold",
   "confidence": 0.85,
   "reason": "One retailer writes the same eau de parfum intense two ways, One Million Gold in Bogota and Million Gold in Panama, at the same two quantities of 100 ml and 200 ml. That is one product line written with and without its leading word, and I would name it Million Gold, the spelling both shops already use for the Elixir beside it.",
   "precedent": "name-a-product-line:head-word-dropped",
   "precedent_status": "sets",
   "attention": "critical",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/BOG/42758810140747",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      38
     ],
     "text": "One Million Gold Intense Eau de Parfum"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/PTY/51191286956312",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      34
     ],
     "text": "Million Gold Eau de Parfum Intense"
    }
   ],
   "position": 6
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:new:rabanne-paco-rose",
   "entity": {
    "type": "product_line",
    "key": "line:new:rabanne-paco-rose",
    "detail": {
     "brand_slug": "rabanne",
     "slug": "rabanne-paco-rose",
     "name": "Paco Rosé",
     "absorbs": [
      "line:8ab79630-a2e8-4c16-a6a0-d46cdfe62542"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "name",
   "value": "Paco Rosé",
   "confidence": 0.9,
   "reason": "One retailer sells article 6981416 at four shops: two write Paco Rosé 100ml and two write Rabanne Paco Rosé 100ml Eau de Toilette. The concentration is a fact about the product variant and does not belong in the product line's name, so these are one product line and the name is Paco Rosé.",
   "precedent": "membership:concentration-in-the-name",
   "precedent_status": "sets",
   "attention": "critical",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:avolta/ATH/6981416",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      39
     ],
     "text": "Rabanne Paco Rosé 100ml Eau de Toilette"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:avolta/ZRH/6981416",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      15
     ],
     "text": "Paco Rosé 100ml"
    }
   ],
   "position": 7
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:new:rabanne-xs-pour-homme",
   "entity": {
    "type": "product_line",
    "key": "line:new:rabanne-xs-pour-homme",
    "detail": {
     "brand_slug": "rabanne",
     "slug": "rabanne-xs-pour-homme",
     "name": "XS Pour Homme",
     "absorbs": [
      "line:ec74a978-d127-4d92-a352-c3cfe6c840ce"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "name",
   "value": "XS Pour Homme",
   "confidence": 0.85,
   "reason": "One retailer writes the same 100 ml eau de toilette as XS Pour Homme in Bogota and San Salvador and as XS For Him in Panama, so it is one product line in two languages. I would keep the French spelling, because that is the name the house puts on the bottle.",
   "precedent": "name-a-product-line:translation-pair",
   "precedent_status": "sets",
   "attention": "critical",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/BOG/42758810828875",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      29
     ],
     "text": "XS Pour Homme Eau de Toilette"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/PTY/51191287841048",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      26
     ],
     "text": "XS For Him Eau de Toilette"
    }
   ],
   "position": 8
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:new:rabanne-pour-homme",
   "entity": {
    "type": "product_line",
    "key": "line:new:rabanne-pour-homme",
    "detail": {
     "brand_slug": "rabanne",
     "slug": "rabanne-pour-homme",
     "name": "Pour Homme",
     "absorbs": [
      "line:da7c4a13-4033-4ca8-ba90-6594a239a58a",
      "line:9995d4e1-0533-453c-863f-517ef9cd1018",
      "line:9410d1e5-5333-4882-bf9c-9af5b01e5e97"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "name",
   "value": "Pour Homme",
   "confidence": 0.75,
   "reason": "Bogota writes Paco Rabanne Pour Homme Eau de Toilette, the house's old name in full followed by the scent, so the leftover Paco belongs to the brand and not to the product line's name. Panama lists For Him Eau de Toilette beside its own XS For Him and Black XS For Him, so the plain spelling is a third, unmarked men's scent, and Montreal writes the same 100 ml eau de toilette as Rabanne for men; I would gather the three rows as Pour Homme.",
   "precedent": "name-a-product-line:former-brand-name-in-the-name",
   "precedent_status": "sets",
   "attention": "critical",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/BOG/42758541377611",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      13,
      23
     ],
     "text": "Pour Homme"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/PTY/52108250743064",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      23
     ],
     "text": "For Him Eau de Toilette"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:ari/YUL/41434724204621",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      25
     ],
     "text": "Rabanne for men EDT 100ml"
    }
   ],
   "position": 9
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:f6e3178d-aaa6-4dc4-a257-01dcd75d69ef",
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:line:line:123c16e0-da69-4b9f-adf3-a6d6299ae439||line:f6e3178d-aaa6-4dc4-a257-01dcd75d69ef",
    "detail": {
     "sides": [
      {
       "key": "line:123c16e0-da69-4b9f-adf3-a6d6299ae439",
       "kind": "product_line",
       "name": "Invictus"
      },
      {
       "key": "line:f6e3178d-aaa6-4dc4-a257-01dcd75d69ef",
       "kind": "product_line",
       "name": "Invictus Deodorant"
      }
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate",
    "note": "A toiletry sold under a scent's name keeps its own product line."
   },
   "confidence": 0.8,
   "reason": "A deodorant sold under a scent's name is another thing to buy, not another quantity of the scent, and the shop shelves it in toiletries rather than fragrance. Nothing is settled for this yet, and I would keep it as its own product line, because folding it in would stand a 75 ml stick beside the eau de toilette on one comparison, where a shopper would read it as a size to choose. One Million Deodorant Stick beside 1 Million is the same case and waits on this answer.",
   "precedent": "membership:format-under-a-scent-name",
   "precedent_status": "sets",
   "attention": "critical",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:avolta/HEL/3349668515752",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      23
     ],
     "text": "Invictus Deodorant 75ml"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:avolta/HEL/3349668515752",
     "source": "listed_category",
     "span": [
      0,
      19
     ],
     "text": "beauty > toiletries"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/BOG/42758809485387",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      24
     ],
     "text": "Invictus Eau de Toilette"
    }
   ],
   "position": 10
  }
 ]
}