{
 "pass": {
  "name": "claude/2026-09-20/johnnie-walker-cross_divide-1",
  "kind": "session",
  "process_version": "6",
  "rules_version": "6",
  "generator": "claude-session",
  "note": "The packet names no layer, and the brand family holds one row with no aliases, so the brands layer shows no question this pass can see; the cross-divide layer holds 31 candidates, so that is the layer worked. The register is empty, so all six kinds named here are new and each lead is critical by construction.\n\nThe packet's cross-divide reading suggests Confirm same on all 31 candidates. This pass reads 28 of them as different Johnnie Walker expressions that share only the brand and a size, and proposes Keep separate so they stop coming back. The candidate rule matches on shared whole words, which cuts both ways: it offers pairs joined by nothing but 'walker' or '1l', and it cannot offer a pair where a shop's shorthand shares no word at all with the retail wording. One such pair, 'Joh.Walk Bl. L. 40% 0.05L PET' beside 'Black Label Aged 12 Year Old Blended Scotch Whisky 5cl', is proposed here even though the packet did not list it; reject that one row if you would rather it came through the candidate list.\n\nTen kinds in the survey belong to the layers after this one and nothing is proposed on them: the missing Label word, the appended category words, the silent age, the travel-retail marker, the packs, the edition words, the Elusive Umami and Azure rows whose barcode side also carries words, the two barcodes at one size, the stated strength, and the wrong category.\n\nTwo things the packet could not give. A second Collection Pack Set product variant at a stated 1600 ml carries no listings at all, so there is no text to cite and nothing can be proposed about it. And one product variant sits under Cognac and Brandy while every sibling sits under Whisky; the file has no field for a category, so it can only be named here.",
  "survey": [
   {
    "kind": "one bottle written at two lengths across the barcode divide",
    "precedent": "cross-divide:same-bottle",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:dubai-duty-free/DXB/106500308",
     "listing:avolta/HEL/1000098"
    ],
    "question": "Is Johnnie Walker Red Label at 500 ml on the barcode side the same product variant as the 50cl of the same expression on the named side, when this brand holds a second barcoded Red Label at 500 ml?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "a container word stated on the barcode side and silent on the named side",
    "precedent": "cross-divide:packaging-word-one-side",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000070261",
     "listing:the-loop/DUB/352203"
    ],
    "question": "Does a stated PET keep a 5 cl miniature apart from the same expression at the same size, whose shop never names the material?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "a shop's shorthand that shares no whole word with the retail wording",
    "precedent": "cross-divide:abbreviation-shares-no-word",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000705609",
     "listing:avolta/JFK/5000267023625-P::50"
    ],
    "question": "Is 'Joh.Walk Bl. L. 40% 0.05L PET' the Black Label 5 cl another shop writes out in full, when the two wordings have no word in common?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "a set named by its box on one side and by its members on the other",
    "precedent": "cross-divide:set-named-by-its-members",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:dubai-duty-free/DXB/110293242",
     "listing:attenza/SAL/48553600647360"
    ],
    "question": "Is a 'Gift Collection Blended Scotch Whisky 4x200ml' the same set as a 'Collection Pack Set Black, Gold, 18, & Blue Label Scotch Whisky (4X200ml.)'?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "two different expressions that share only the brand and a size",
    "precedent": "cross-divide:different-expression",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:dubai-duty-free/DXB/111588472",
     "listing:attenza/SAL/48553600745664"
    ],
    "question": "Should a candidate whose two sides name different expressions be recorded as Keep separate, so it never returns?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "the barcode side written as the shop's own abbreviation",
    "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000001581996",
     "listing:ari/YUL/41367643553869"
    ],
    "question": "Does 'Blue Xord' read as Blue Label Xordinaire, so the plain Blue beside it is a different bottle?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "a Label word on some sibling names and absent on one",
    "precedent": "name-a-product-line:label-word-absent",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:ari/YUL/41367646896205",
     "listing:avolta/LHR/5000267023625-P::1000"
    ],
    "question": "Is 'Johnnie Walker Black' the Black Label product line written short or a product line of its own, with neither assumed to be the parent of the other?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "a category descriptor appended by some shops and not others",
    "precedent": "name-a-product-line:category-words-appended",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:the-loop/DUB/018977",
     "listing:ari/YUL/41374365679693"
    ],
    "question": "Do 'Blended Scotch Whisky', 'Blended Scotch' and 'Whisky' make separate product lines, or is one product line being written at different lengths?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "an age stated on some sibling names and silent on others",
    "precedent": "membership:age-stated-on-some",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:extime/CDG/100064425",
     "listing:avolta/LHR/5000267023625-P::1000"
    ],
    "question": "Is a Black Label with no stated age the twelve-year-old product line, or a product line of its own?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "a travel-retail marker on some rows of an otherwise identical name",
    "precedent": "membership:travel-exclusive-marker",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000001207505",
     "listing:extime/CDG/100518106"
    ],
    "question": "Is 'Travel Exclusive' an attribute inside one product line, or a product line of its own?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "a multi-bottle pack of a bottle the catalogue already holds",
    "precedent": "membership:pack-of-the-same-bottle",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:avolta/LHR/5000267164953",
     "listing:attenza/BOG/42758678052939"
    ],
    "question": "Does a twin pack or a triple pack sit inside the single bottle's product line, or is it a product line of its own?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "an edition word on some rows of the same expression",
    "precedent": "membership:edition-word-on-some",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:ari/YUL/41374402773069",
     "listing:attenza/SAL/48553600417984"
    ],
    "question": "Is 'Triple Cask Edition' the same thing as 'Triple Cask', and is an edition word an attribute inside the parent product line or a range the brand sells in its own right?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "one bottle whose barcode side also carries listed words, so this layer never offers the pair",
    "precedent": "product-variant:barcoded-side-also-named",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:extime/CDG/101272550",
     "listing:attenza/PTY/50880964198680"
    ],
    "question": "Should the barcoded Blue Label Elusive Umami and the barcode-less one at another shop become one product variant?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "two barcodes on what reads as one bottle at one size",
    "precedent": "product-variant:two-barcodes-one-size",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:avolta/LGW/5000267013602-P::1000",
     "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000012520"
    ],
    "question": "Are two barcodes on Red Label at one litre two pack presentations, or one product variant?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "a strength stated in the barcode shop's wording and silent in the retail wording",
    "precedent": "product-variant:strength-stated-one-side",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000012520",
     "listing:avolta/LHR/5000267013602-P::1000"
    ],
    "question": "Does a stated 40% beside a name that says nothing about strength keep two rows apart?"
   },
   {
    "kind": "a category that contradicts every sibling",
    "precedent": "attribute:category-contradicts-siblings",
    "registered": false,
    "examples": [
     "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000001581996",
     "listing:heinemann-iceland/KEF/000000000001581996"
    ],
    "question": "Is a Johnnie Walker whisky filed under Cognac and Brandy a fact to correct?"
   }
  ],
  "verdict": "proposals",
  "fingerprint": "f7020f96fa961171b383647877274221c30061c7979258bb5d6d7d8ec54e5851"
 },
 "brand": "johnnie-walker",
 "proposals": [
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:7316b340-1926-4415-a282-111f6eca36d9",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:647da37f-cc68-48d0-9820-7c8d60df5bfb||variant:797606da-856d-4a3f-969b-76a2b313ce20",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:647da37f-cc68-48d0-9820-7c8d60df5bfb",
      "variant:797606da-856d-4a3f-969b-76a2b313ce20"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "same",
    "survivor": "variant:797606da-856d-4a3f-969b-76a2b313ce20"
   },
   "confidence": 0.65,
   "reason": "These read as one bottle, Johnnie Walker Red Label at 500 ml, written 500ml by the shop that publishes a barcode and 50cl by the shop that does not, and the barcode is what makes a cross-shop comparison possible, so the barcoded product variant should survive. Be warned that this brand holds a second barcoded Red Label at 500 ml, so the 50cl row could belong to that one instead, and that is the part only you can settle.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:same-bottle",
   "precedent_status": "sets",
   "attention": "critical",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:dubai-duty-free/DXB/106500308",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      52
     ],
     "text": "Red Label Blended Scotch Whisky 500ml"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:avolta/HEL/1000098",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      21
     ],
     "text": "Red Label Whisky 50cl"
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:4be999bd-ae68-4729-a510-e0c76babc3c8",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:6e0b1071-2032-4f22-bf65-8e1e52d0cdb8||variant:7221cf8c-0e68-45d7-bf34-b340e46baf2b",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:6e0b1071-2032-4f22-bf65-8e1e52d0cdb8",
      "variant:7221cf8c-0e68-45d7-bf34-b340e46baf2b"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "same",
    "survivor": "variant:7221cf8c-0e68-45d7-bf34-b340e46baf2b"
   },
   "confidence": 0.8,
   "reason": "Both sides are Johnnie Walker Red Label at 5 cl; the shop with the barcode adds PET, its word for the plastic miniature, and the other shop never says what its miniature is made of. A word stated on one side beside a silent name is not agreement by itself, so the question is whether PET is a difference worth keeping two product variants apart.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:packaging-word-one-side",
   "precedent_status": "sets",
   "attention": "critical",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000070261",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      29
     ],
     "text": "Joh.Walk Red L. 40% 0.05L PET"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:the-loop/DUB/352203",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      31
     ],
     "text": "Red Label Blended Scotch Whisky"
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:7800ffd9-0fba-4db5-9ed3-13bb06e980d1",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:49dc0dc7-634d-4025-be24-714edda5b7a8||variant:b1772202-7c14-4bdc-b710-f75160f1636f",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:49dc0dc7-634d-4025-be24-714edda5b7a8",
      "variant:b1772202-7c14-4bdc-b710-f75160f1636f"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "same",
    "survivor": "variant:49dc0dc7-634d-4025-be24-714edda5b7a8"
   },
   "confidence": 0.7,
   "reason": "'Joh.Walk Bl. L.' at 0.05L is Black Label at 5 cl, read the same way as the same shop's 'Joh.Walk Red L.' beside Red Label, and the two wordings share no whole word at all, so nothing but that reading joins them. The retail side also states the twelve-year age the shorthand leaves out, and this pair is not among the candidates the packet offered.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:abbreviation-shares-no-word",
   "precedent_status": "sets",
   "attention": "critical",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000705609",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      29
     ],
     "text": "Joh.Walk Bl. L. 40% 0.05L PET"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:avolta/JFK/5000267023625-P::50",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      54
     ],
     "text": "Black Label Aged 12 Year Old Blended Scotch Whisky 5cl"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000070261",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      15
     ],
     "text": "Joh.Walk Red L."
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:6ad142d2-de87-42e2-a5cc-edb87b7f891f",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:3a956d58-206a-463a-a921-b79aa4956c7f||variant:a70e1cac-a4e1-458d-92be-32ab739e17d5",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:3a956d58-206a-463a-a921-b79aa4956c7f",
      "variant:a70e1cac-a4e1-458d-92be-32ab739e17d5"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "same",
    "survivor": "variant:3a956d58-206a-463a-a921-b79aa4956c7f"
   },
   "confidence": 0.6,
   "reason": "Both sides are a four-bottle Johnnie Walker collection of 200 ml bottles totalling 800 ml, one shop naming the box and the other naming what is inside it. Nothing in either wording rules out a second four-by-200 ml Johnnie Walker collection, so this is a reading rather than a certainty.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:set-named-by-its-members",
   "precedent_status": "sets",
   "attention": "critical",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:dubai-duty-free/DXB/110293242",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      60
     ],
     "text": "Gift Collection Blended Scotch Whisky 4x200ml"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/SAL/48553600647360",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      89
     ],
     "text": "Collection Pack Set Black, Gold, 18, & Blue Label Scotch Whisky (4X200ml.)"
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:eae1b415-c08b-458b-b9a1-ca21e759f441",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:0939df2b-f02d-46cb-a3f1-e8e56c2e7077||variant:ab316556-2877-4df1-b96a-d132df8a86c2",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:0939df2b-f02d-46cb-a3f1-e8e56c2e7077",
      "variant:ab316556-2877-4df1-b96a-d132df8a86c2"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.95,
   "reason": "Red Label and Gold Label Reserve are different Johnnie Walker expressions, and all the two sides share is the brand and a three-litre total. Answering this holds back the seven other pairs of this kind, which set Red Label, Black Label at twelve years, Master's Ruby Reserve at forty years and The John Walker Triple Matured against Red Label at 50cl, Blue Label King George V, Blue Azure, Blue Label Elusive Umami, plain Blue Label, XR at twenty-one years and Gold Label Reserve.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "sets",
   "attention": "critical",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:dubai-duty-free/DXB/111588472",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      24
     ],
     "text": "Red Label"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/SAL/48553600745664",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      33
     ],
     "text": "Gold Label Reserve"
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:7316b340-1926-4415-a282-111f6eca36d9",
   "position": 1,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:647da37f-cc68-48d0-9820-7c8d60df5bfb||variant:82bfa5ed-8ccf-4874-9b92-03de8388bdf3",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:647da37f-cc68-48d0-9820-7c8d60df5bfb",
      "variant:82bfa5ed-8ccf-4874-9b92-03de8388bdf3"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.95,
   "reason": "Black Label at twelve years and Red Label are different Johnnie Walker expressions; the two sides share only the brand and the 500 ml size.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:dubai-duty-free/DXB/106500307",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      40
     ],
     "text": "Black Label Aged 12 Years"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:avolta/HEL/1000098",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      21
     ],
     "text": "Red Label Whisky 50cl"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:0939df2b-f02d-46cb-a3f1-e8e56c2e7077||variant:ab316556-2877-4df1-b96a-d132df8a86c2"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:bb9a256a-b7a0-4564-ba95-497a24478245",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:be414caa-77df-4b9a-ae43-492966656d8e||variant:e130685a-32b4-4bb8-95fc-37bcb31c6e87",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:be414caa-77df-4b9a-ae43-492966656d8e",
      "variant:e130685a-32b4-4bb8-95fc-37bcb31c6e87"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.95,
   "reason": "Master's Ruby Reserve at forty years and Blue Label King George V are different Johnnie Walker expressions that happen to share a 700 ml size.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:dubai-duty-free/DXB/113543221",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      49
     ],
     "text": "Master's Ruby Reserve 40 Years Old"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:avolta/LHR/2070364000006",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      24
     ],
     "text": "Blue Label King George V"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:0939df2b-f02d-46cb-a3f1-e8e56c2e7077||variant:ab316556-2877-4df1-b96a-d132df8a86c2"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:7f1f03e6-ee30-47ab-8941-1632c6709eb4",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:2bc00934-2c98-4608-84f4-43dce57dfee1||variant:cb15ed87-f123-4065-8f7d-601b65d58dec",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:2bc00934-2c98-4608-84f4-43dce57dfee1",
      "variant:cb15ed87-f123-4065-8f7d-601b65d58dec"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.95,
   "reason": "The John Walker Triple Matured and Blue Label Elusive Umami are different Johnnie Walker expressions that happen to share a 750 ml size.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:dubai-duty-free/DXB/110073068",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      19,
      49
     ],
     "text": "The John Walker Triple Matured"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/BOG/42758678478923",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      39
     ],
     "text": "Blue Label Elusive Umami"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:0939df2b-f02d-46cb-a3f1-e8e56c2e7077||variant:ab316556-2877-4df1-b96a-d132df8a86c2"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:8e995797-8117-43b7-87be-83aea25bde97",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:2fb8e7f7-30a7-455b-8cc0-6b3739fb3743||variant:cb15ed87-f123-4065-8f7d-601b65d58dec",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:2fb8e7f7-30a7-455b-8cc0-6b3739fb3743",
      "variant:cb15ed87-f123-4065-8f7d-601b65d58dec"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.95,
   "reason": "The John Walker Triple Matured and plain Blue Label are different Johnnie Walker expressions that happen to share a 750 ml size.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:dubai-duty-free/DXB/110073068",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      19,
      49
     ],
     "text": "The John Walker Triple Matured"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/SAL/48553600516288",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      47
     ],
     "text": "Blue Label Blended Scotch Whisky"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:0939df2b-f02d-46cb-a3f1-e8e56c2e7077||variant:ab316556-2877-4df1-b96a-d132df8a86c2"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:706912ec-e3f1-4249-b629-85fb231bf5e4",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:3a362850-f515-465b-af77-d1edb21a6bb9||variant:e130685a-32b4-4bb8-95fc-37bcb31c6e87",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:3a362850-f515-465b-af77-d1edb21a6bb9",
      "variant:e130685a-32b4-4bb8-95fc-37bcb31c6e87"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.95,
   "reason": "Master's Ruby Reserve at forty years and Blue Azure are different Johnnie Walker expressions that happen to share a 700 ml size.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:dubai-duty-free/DXB/113543221",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      49
     ],
     "text": "Master's Ruby Reserve 40 Years Old"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:avolta/LGW/7268559",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      10
     ],
     "text": "Blue Azure"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:0939df2b-f02d-46cb-a3f1-e8e56c2e7077||variant:ab316556-2877-4df1-b96a-d132df8a86c2"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:1d5b8886-a07e-43b8-bd5e-d16f8574a8e6",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:5e6e23ef-610d-4bde-a6b0-d75a42b3a1e9||variant:cb15ed87-f123-4065-8f7d-601b65d58dec",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:5e6e23ef-610d-4bde-a6b0-d75a42b3a1e9",
      "variant:cb15ed87-f123-4065-8f7d-601b65d58dec"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.95,
   "reason": "The John Walker Triple Matured and XR at twenty-one years are different Johnnie Walker expressions that happen to share a 750 ml size.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:dubai-duty-free/DXB/110073068",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      19,
      49
     ],
     "text": "The John Walker Triple Matured"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/BOG/42758680641611",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      52
     ],
     "text": "XR Blended Scotch Whisky 21 Years Old"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:0939df2b-f02d-46cb-a3f1-e8e56c2e7077||variant:ab316556-2877-4df1-b96a-d132df8a86c2"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:d37cb493-4ea6-4938-91bc-baa69aac6879",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:11aaf333-70e2-49bb-91f6-c144c5e4f48c||variant:cb15ed87-f123-4065-8f7d-601b65d58dec",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:11aaf333-70e2-49bb-91f6-c144c5e4f48c",
      "variant:cb15ed87-f123-4065-8f7d-601b65d58dec"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.95,
   "reason": "The John Walker Triple Matured and Gold Label Reserve are different Johnnie Walker expressions that happen to share a 750 ml size.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:dubai-duty-free/DXB/110073068",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      19,
      49
     ],
     "text": "The John Walker Triple Matured"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:avolta/EZE/2092231180031-P::750",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      23
     ],
     "text": "Gold Label Reserve 75cl"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:0939df2b-f02d-46cb-a3f1-e8e56c2e7077||variant:ab316556-2877-4df1-b96a-d132df8a86c2"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:0591f209-175b-4166-9ef2-3348fba8d0cb",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0",
      "variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.92,
   "reason": "'Blue Xord' is this shop's short way of writing Blue Label Xordinaire, and the shop on the other side of the pair lists that same bottle under its own full name, so the plain Blue beside it is a different Johnnie Walker expression. Answering this holds back the nineteen other pairs of this kind, which set the shorthands Joh.Walk Red Label, Joh.Walk Blue L. and Joh. Walker Blue Xord against Island Green, plain Black, Gold Reserve, Black Label at twelve years, Blue Label The Casks Edition, Blue Label Elusive Umami, Black Label Triple Cask Edition, Blue Label King George V, plain Blue and Blue Azure.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "sets",
   "attention": "critical",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000001581996",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      12,
      21
     ],
     "text": "Blue Xord"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:ari/YUL/41367643553869",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      22
     ],
     "text": "Johnnie Walker Blue 1L"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:ari/YUL/41367641292877",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      36
     ],
     "text": "Blue Label Xordinaire"
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:e29fdaf5-599b-4cc4-bf0c-18e7ef7faa24",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:026caf02-2ea7-483b-885c-cf9fba485200||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:026caf02-2ea7-483b-885c-cf9fba485200",
      "variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.92,
   "reason": "'Blue Xord' reads as Blue Label Xordinaire, which is not Gold Reserve; the two sides share only the brand and the one-litre size.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000001581996",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      12,
      21
     ],
     "text": "Blue Xord"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:ari/YUL/41367643488333",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      27
     ],
     "text": "Gold Reserve"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:a5d2de78-6160-4e1e-9a18-c774915faeee",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:08178669-950c-4ab3-8343-162a0cf23193||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:08178669-950c-4ab3-8343-162a0cf23193",
      "variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.92,
   "reason": "'Blue Xord' reads as Blue Label Xordinaire, which is not Island Green; the two sides share only the brand and the one-litre size.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000001581996",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      12,
      21
     ],
     "text": "Blue Xord"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:avolta/LGW/2500530",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      12
     ],
     "text": "Island Green"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:60a0708d-890f-41da-810f-5f7a7e3b9984",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:1ae89a5c-e496-4862-a668-68036c379370||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:1ae89a5c-e496-4862-a668-68036c379370",
      "variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.92,
   "reason": "'Blue Xord' reads as Blue Label Xordinaire, which is not the plain Black the other shop sells; the two sides share only the brand and the one-litre size.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000001581996",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      12,
      21
     ],
     "text": "Blue Xord"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:ari/YUL/41367646896205",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      23
     ],
     "text": "Johnnie Walker Black 1L"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:3aad1739-763b-4ae9-b6bb-113bea86add4",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:24fd175d-d265-48dd-a752-bf87ba8286ef||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:24fd175d-d265-48dd-a752-bf87ba8286ef",
      "variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.9,
   "reason": "Xordinaire and The Casks Edition are two separately named Blue Label editions, so the shorthand 'Blue Xord' does not reach this one.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000001581996",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      12,
      21
     ],
     "text": "Blue Xord"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/PTY/50880964264216",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      43
     ],
     "text": "Blue Label The Casks Edition"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:7a3be9c3-1e2f-4486-93a9-8ddfc31e5402",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07||variant:bb4c8728-6e42-4c59-aab9-a671c32e1cf1",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07",
      "variant:bb4c8728-6e42-4c59-aab9-a671c32e1cf1"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.93,
   "reason": "'Joh.Walk Red Label' is Red Label written short, and Black Label Triple Cask Edition is a different Johnnie Walker expression.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000012520",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      18
     ],
     "text": "Joh.Walk Red Label"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:avolta/LGW/2935336",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      31
     ],
     "text": "Black Label Triple Cask Edition"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:7f1f03e6-ee30-47ab-8941-1632c6709eb4",
   "position": 1,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:6f370899-77f9-4da1-a292-64f3cb687b7e||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:6f370899-77f9-4da1-a292-64f3cb687b7e",
      "variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.9,
   "reason": "Xordinaire and Elusive Umami are two separately named Blue Label editions, so the shorthand 'Blue Xord' does not reach this one.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000001581996",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      12,
      21
     ],
     "text": "Blue Xord"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/PTY/50880964198680",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      39
     ],
     "text": "Blue Label Elusive Umami"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:780a0889-1318-4948-bf1e-f93d6c1e8646",
   "position": 0,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:826a350b-fbe8-4d49-9caf-5bd4ef1fe7cc||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:826a350b-fbe8-4d49-9caf-5bd4ef1fe7cc",
      "variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.92,
   "reason": "'Blue Xord' reads as Blue Label Xordinaire, which is not the Island Green this other shop sells at the same one-litre size.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000001581996",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      12,
      21
     ],
     "text": "Blue Xord"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:ari/YUL/41367642898509",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      27
     ],
     "text": "Island Green"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:7a3be9c3-1e2f-4486-93a9-8ddfc31e5402",
   "position": 1,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:bb4c8728-6e42-4c59-aab9-a671c32e1cf1||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:bb4c8728-6e42-4c59-aab9-a671c32e1cf1",
      "variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.92,
   "reason": "'Blue Xord' reads as Blue Label Xordinaire, which is not Black Label Triple Cask Edition.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000001581996",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      12,
      21
     ],
     "text": "Blue Xord"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:avolta/LGW/2935336",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      31
     ],
     "text": "Black Label Triple Cask Edition"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:e29fdaf5-599b-4cc4-bf0c-18e7ef7faa24",
   "position": 1,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:026caf02-2ea7-483b-885c-cf9fba485200||variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:026caf02-2ea7-483b-885c-cf9fba485200",
      "variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.93,
   "reason": "'Joh.Walk Red Label' is Red Label written short, and Gold Reserve is a different Johnnie Walker expression.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000012520",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      18
     ],
     "text": "Joh.Walk Red Label"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:ari/YUL/41367643488333",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      27
     ],
     "text": "Gold Reserve"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:a5d2de78-6160-4e1e-9a18-c774915faeee",
   "position": 1,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:08178669-950c-4ab3-8343-162a0cf23193||variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:08178669-950c-4ab3-8343-162a0cf23193",
      "variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.93,
   "reason": "'Joh.Walk Red Label' is Red Label written short, and Island Green is a different Johnnie Walker expression.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000012520",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      18
     ],
     "text": "Joh.Walk Red Label"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:avolta/LGW/2500530",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      12
     ],
     "text": "Island Green"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:60a0708d-890f-41da-810f-5f7a7e3b9984",
   "position": 1,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:1ae89a5c-e496-4862-a668-68036c379370||variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:1ae89a5c-e496-4862-a668-68036c379370",
      "variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.93,
   "reason": "'Joh.Walk Red Label' is Red Label written short, and the plain Black the other shop sells is a different Johnnie Walker expression.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000012520",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      18
     ],
     "text": "Joh.Walk Red Label"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:ari/YUL/41367646896205",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      23
     ],
     "text": "Johnnie Walker Black 1L"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:7800ffd9-0fba-4db5-9ed3-13bb06e980d1",
   "position": 1,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:244d2f80-d975-4a78-ab11-4ce74696fe99||variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:244d2f80-d975-4a78-ab11-4ce74696fe99",
      "variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.93,
   "reason": "'Joh.Walk Red Label' is Red Label written short, and Black Label at twelve years is a different Johnnie Walker expression.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000012520",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      18
     ],
     "text": "Joh.Walk Red Label"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/SAL/48553592160448",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      40
     ],
     "text": "Black Label Aged 12 Years"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:7800ffd9-0fba-4db5-9ed3-13bb06e980d1",
   "position": 2,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:244d2f80-d975-4a78-ab11-4ce74696fe99||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:244d2f80-d975-4a78-ab11-4ce74696fe99",
      "variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.93,
   "reason": "'Blue Xord' reads as Blue Label Xordinaire, which is not Black Label at twelve years.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000001581996",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      12,
      21
     ],
     "text": "Blue Xord"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/SAL/48553592160448",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      40
     ],
     "text": "Black Label Aged 12 Years"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:3aad1739-763b-4ae9-b6bb-113bea86add4",
   "position": 1,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:24fd175d-d265-48dd-a752-bf87ba8286ef||variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:24fd175d-d265-48dd-a752-bf87ba8286ef",
      "variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.93,
   "reason": "'Joh.Walk Red Label' is Red Label written short, and Blue Label The Casks Edition is a different Johnnie Walker expression.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000012520",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      18
     ],
     "text": "Joh.Walk Red Label"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/PTY/50880964264216",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      43
     ],
     "text": "Blue Label The Casks Edition"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:706912ec-e3f1-4249-b629-85fb231bf5e4",
   "position": 1,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:3a362850-f515-465b-af77-d1edb21a6bb9||variant:8fa8b248-bcc1-4ef4-8889-92bd1bf2dc13",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:3a362850-f515-465b-af77-d1edb21a6bb9",
      "variant:8fa8b248-bcc1-4ef4-8889-92bd1bf2dc13"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.9,
   "reason": "'Joh.Walk Blue L.' is plain Blue Label written short, and the same shop writes the Azure edition as 'Joh.Walk Blue L.Azure', so the Azure on the other side is a different bottle.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000518250",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      16
     ],
     "text": "Joh.Walk Blue L."
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:avolta/LGW/7268559",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      10
     ],
     "text": "Blue Azure"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000001772841",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      9,
      21
     ],
     "text": "Blue L.Azure"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:7f1f03e6-ee30-47ab-8941-1632c6709eb4",
   "position": 2,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07||variant:6f370899-77f9-4da1-a292-64f3cb687b7e",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07",
      "variant:6f370899-77f9-4da1-a292-64f3cb687b7e"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.93,
   "reason": "'Joh.Walk Red Label' is Red Label written short, and Blue Label Elusive Umami is a different Johnnie Walker expression.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000012520",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      18
     ],
     "text": "Joh.Walk Red Label"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:attenza/PTY/50880964198680",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      39
     ],
     "text": "Blue Label Elusive Umami"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:780a0889-1318-4948-bf1e-f93d6c1e8646",
   "position": 1,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07||variant:826a350b-fbe8-4d49-9caf-5bd4ef1fe7cc",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07",
      "variant:826a350b-fbe8-4d49-9caf-5bd4ef1fe7cc"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.93,
   "reason": "'Joh.Walk Red Label' is Red Label written short, and the Island Green this other shop sells is a different Johnnie Walker expression.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000012520",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      18
     ],
     "text": "Joh.Walk Red Label"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:ari/YUL/41367642898509",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      15,
      27
     ],
     "text": "Island Green"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:0591f209-175b-4166-9ef2-3348fba8d0cb",
   "position": 1,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07||variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:68366ea1-67a1-4a86-bcb9-8f9f6e052e07",
      "variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.93,
   "reason": "'Joh.Walk Red Label' is Red Label written short, and plain Blue is a different Johnnie Walker expression.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000012520",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      18
     ],
     "text": "Joh.Walk Red Label"
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:ari/YUL/41367643553869",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      22
     ],
     "text": "Johnnie Walker Blue 1L"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  },
  {
   "sheet_line_ref": "line:bb9a256a-b7a0-4564-ba95-497a24478245",
   "position": 1,
   "entity": {
    "type": "suggestion",
    "key": "pair:product:variant:8fa8b248-bcc1-4ef4-8889-92bd1bf2dc13||variant:be414caa-77df-4b9a-ae43-492966656d8e",
    "detail": {
     "level": "product",
     "sides": [
      "variant:8fa8b248-bcc1-4ef4-8889-92bd1bf2dc13",
      "variant:be414caa-77df-4b9a-ae43-492966656d8e"
     ]
    }
   },
   "field": "decision",
   "value": {
    "decision": "separate"
   },
   "confidence": 0.9,
   "reason": "'Joh.Walk Blue L.' is plain Blue Label written short, and King George V is its own Johnnie Walker expression at the same 700 ml size.",
   "precedent": "cross-divide:shorthand-different-expression",
   "precedent_status": "follows",
   "attention": "none",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "listing": "listing:heinemann/HEINEMANN-GLOBAL/000000000000518250",
     "source": "collected_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      16
     ],
     "text": "Joh.Walk Blue L."
    },
    {
     "listing": "listing:avolta/LHR/2070364000006",
     "source": "listed_name",
     "span": [
      0,
      24
     ],
     "text": "Blue Label King George V"
    }
   ],
   "follows": "pair:product:variant:9b17cb69-6b88-4ac1-b195-cbc9b674a2c0||variant:d924f2fb-aac4-49ff-9620-e43c2f110dc0"
  }
 ]
}